Myrtle Bagel
Looking for a place to grab a delicious bagel in Brooklyn? Let me introduce you to Myrtle Bagel, a hidden gem located at 410 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205. This cozy spot offers a casual vibe, making it a perfect hangout for anyone in the neighborhood. Whether you’re dining alone or with friends, Myrtle Bagel provides a quiet atmosphere that's also great for families and even your furry friends (yes, dogs are welcome here!).
One of the things that sets Myrtle Bagel apart is its diverse menu, with something for everyone. If you’re a fan of classic flavors, don’t miss the Everything Bagel Cross—it’s a local favorite that brings all the best bagel flavors together in one bite. If you’re craving something hearty, you’ll love the Italian Chicken Sandwich, which is loaded with flavor, or try the Chicken Cordon Bleu Sandwich for a rich and satisfying meal. There’s also a great selection of lighter options like the Egg Salad or the Egg White Sandwich, perfect if you’re looking for something a little less heavy but still packed with taste.
Myrtle Bagel is not just about the food—it’s also about the experience. The relaxed, low-key vibe makes it an ideal spot for groups to get together, enjoy a meal, and unwind. It’s definitely a place where you can kick back and feel at home. Whether you're coming for a quick bite or planning to spend a little more time, this place has got you covered.
So, next time you’re in Brooklyn, make sure to stop by Myrtle Bagel. You won’t regret it!
Reviews
Delicious. Been eating here for years, it will be a lil slower coming in placing an order. So I recommend call ahead. All of their egg white sandwiches, awesome.
This was my first time coming here to get a breakfast sandwich. I got one of the egg white special sandwiches with added turkey and I have to say it was good maybe too much cheese in it but overall it was good and I would come back to try other things. The place looks nice and there's plenty of things to choose from. My next choice would obviously be what the place is named after which is a bagel! They also seem to have a very nice selection of different cream cheese.
Pretty solid bagel sandwich. I got a Whole wheat everything with tofu cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. I'm glad they have vegan cream cheese options so everyone can find something they like.
This was one of the only places in the area open on Thanksgiving. They had a lot of options on the menu, but after all of us decided what we wanted to order they told us the grill was off and they wouldn't be able to make most of what we wanted (?!) - we came in the afternoon so maybe it's only on in the mornings, but it was still pretty strange and they should have mentioned that first. Then after ordering a few bagels and a sandwich, the wait time was pretty long, and it was cold inside while we waited - the tables are right by the door so it's not a great place to eat in the colder months. But the main reason for 4 stars: I finally ended up getting my eggplant sandwich and took it to-go, and it was DELICIOUS (but oily, as expected) - I've been craving it ever since.
I only stop in here to grab bagels to go, so can't speak to any of the other items, but the bagels are awesome. The price is definitely affordable, and the staff hustle to get everything done. No complaints from me if you want a solid bagel.